Florida Learjet crash

About ATC denying the request- this is all pretty normal stuff. ATC is primarily dealing with keeping traffic separated. They can't approve turning you into another airplanes space.

Once you use emergency authority, its then their job to redirect the other airplanes in the area.

This is all pretty normal thinderstorm stuff happens weekly down in FLA.
 
About ATC denying the request- this is all pretty normal stuff. ATC is primarily dealing with keeping traffic separated. They can't approve turning you into another airplanes space.

Once you use emergency authority, its then their job to redirect the other airplanes in the area.

This is all pretty normal thinderstorm stuff happens weekly down in FLA.
I didn't bring it up to identify establish norms but that it in this investigation it will be a factor in the PIC/ATC decision making process.

They will go look at PIC's countermand history I'm sure. I did see another news media post that tail 722 was possibly involved in another severe turbulence event a few months ago. Not sure of the facts of how that flight and the post flight inspection played out.
 
Last edited:
About ATC denying the request- this is all pretty normal stuff. ATC is primarily dealing with keeping traffic separated. They can't approve turning you into another airplanes space.

Once you use emergency authority, its then their job to redirect the other airplanes in the area.

This is all pretty normal thinderstorm stuff happens weekly down in FLA.
Thanks for the explanation
 
This is the most informative thread I have seen on this horrific accident , so I will ask my stupid question here. The plane seemed to go into the ground under full throttle, why not cut the power as soon as the overspeed condition occurs ?
 
Sounds like you have much more emergency situation experience than almost any random person youd pick off the street. I would expect any of them to be looking for things you or I have been trained to assess.

Typo...I meant *wouldn't* expect...
 
This is the most informative thread I have seen on this horrific accident , so I will ask my stupid question here. The plane seemed to go into the ground under full throttle, why not cut the power as soon as the overspeed condition occurs ?
First off, this aircraft was never meant to go nose down like they did. A normal flight profile feeds air into the compressor and the FADEC controls the engine speed/fuel as your flying.

So, when the aircraft engines exceeds its established speed limits due to the nose over "mach tuck" the engines will often overspeed and exceed max limits. It can cause the engine to compressor stall and literally come apart internally as they push past 105% (example of a max limit) and often times sound like they are screaming.
 
Last edited:
Juan Browne’s Analysis, NTSB initial report.
Icing condition, overspeed condition, loss of horizontal stabilizer, probably loss in dive. RIP to all. Very similar to Medivac Lear crash in Philly.
 
Ryan Hall just did a thing on the weather they ran into. Tried to post it in the YouTube thread but as usual I can't get links to work on this new board. Do a search, it was informative.
 
I was hoping you would pop in with your experience and knowledge. I fear this exact thing happing every time I get on a commercial plane, which I understand is less likely to happen. Its nice to read your explanation of how things like this happen and what are possible causes. It wild that more people weren't injured or worse.
FWIW, right after this happened, I was on my way to Mom's for Sunday dinner and saw at least 30 airplanes on the ground in FLL waiting to depart. They are waiting because they won't go anywhere near that weather- everyone is trying to route around it by 50 miles or more- not pick our way through some shrinking 5 mile gap. We CAN do stuff like that, but it's a last resort. Airline world is quite safe. If I say "hell no I'm not flying through that" not one person is going to push back on me. We give this kind of weather a wide berth and if we can't, we just wait it out. Sucks for the passengers but the other option is alot worse.
This is the most informative thread I have seen on this horrific accident , so I will ask my stupid question here. The plane seemed to go into the ground under full throttle, why not cut the power as soon as the overspeed condition occurs ?
Not dumb at all- many pilots don't understand how quickly you can accelerate by pointing the nose down. You can go to idle- and I'm sure they did. Think about this: It's a 23,000 lb airplane. The engines produce 9,000lb of thrust- that is enough to push it up to 51,000 ft and well past 500 knots in level flight. When it's pointed straight down, even if the engines are off, you have 23,000 pounds pushing you forward (force of gravity). So you can imagine how fast it will accelerate when it starts descending.
 
AI kinetic energy calculations, a range of values since the exact speed at impact isn't precisely known. Assuming 25k# including the plane, passengers, luggage, and errata. That's probably a tad low, but kinetic energy varies by the square of the speed. A few pounds plus r minus is minimal.

Standard SI Units (Joules)


This uses a mass of 11,339.81 kg and converts the velocities to meters per second.
  • At 300 mph (134.11 m/s): \(101.97\text{ Megajoules (MJ)}\) or \(101,974,534.6\text{ J}\)
  • At 350 mph (156.46 m/s): \(138.80\text{ Megajoules (MJ)}\) or \(138,798,617.2\text{ J}\)
  • At 400 mph (178.82 m/s): \(181.29\text{ Megajoules (MJ)}\) or \(181,288,061.6\text{ J}\)

To give you an idea of the scale, \(181\text{ MJ}\) of energy at 400 mph is roughly equivalent to detonating 95 pounds of TNT.



(no @HPPT im not a Piled High and Deep Physicist from a Prominent University, but I DID take Mr Meeks' AP physics class in 1985.:moon:
 
Juan Browne’s Analysis, NTSB initial report.
Icing condition, overspeed condition, loss of horizontal stabilizer, probably loss in dive. RIP to all. Very similar to Medivac Lear crash in Philly.
Buddy of mine was:
Apache pilot in the Army during Bosnia
Private helicopter pilot working for air ambulance
Private plane pilot working across multiple types of smaller, private jets.
Worked for the FAA doing certification for helicopter/small planes.
Anything flight related, from crash to general question, he's my go-to guy.

He's also sent me the above video as one that has a comprehensive analysis, prior to the NTSB report.
 
Speculation but I think there was possibility that the previous severe turbulence event (back in May) weakened one if not both of the horizontal stab structure/attach points.
 
Juan Browne’s Analysis, NTSB initial report.
Icing condition, overspeed condition, loss of horizontal stabilizer, probably loss in dive. RIP to all. Very similar to Medivac Lear crash in Philly.
Juan Browne needs fucked with a barbed wire dildo. Speculation for profit on other peoples tragedies, what more can be said about that individuals character?

He went on a blatantly incorrect rant about a friend’s accident. If he had done 3 minutes of research on the internet, he would’ve known he was grossly wrong. If I ever see him at an airport, he’s got a swift kick in the dick for free..
 
Last edited:
AI kinetic energy calculations, a range of values since the exact speed at impact isn't precisely known. Assuming 25k# including the plane, passengers, luggage, and errata. That's probably a tad low, but kinetic energy varies by the square of the speed. A few pounds plus r minus is minimal.

Standard SI Units (Joules)


This uses a mass of 11,339.81 kg and converts the velocities to meters per second.
  • At 300 mph (134.11 m/s): \(101.97\text{ Megajoules (MJ)}\) or \(101,974,534.6\text{ J}\)
  • At 350 mph (156.46 m/s): \(138.80\text{ Megajoules (MJ)}\) or \(138,798,617.2\text{ J}\)
  • At 400 mph (178.82 m/s): \(181.29\text{ Megajoules (MJ)}\) or \(181,288,061.6\text{ J}\)

To give you an idea of the scale, \(181\text{ MJ}\) of energy at 400 mph is roughly equivalent to detonating 95 pounds of TNT.



(no @HPPT im not a Piled High and Deep Physicist from a Prominent University, but I DID take Mr Meeks' AP physics class in 1985.:moon:
My high school physics teacher was an inspiration and mentor for me to engineering and way better than any professor I ever had… :)
 
FWIW, right after this happened, I was on my way to Mom's for Sunday dinner and saw at least 30 airplanes on the ground in FLL waiting to depart. They are waiting because they won't go anywhere near that weather- everyone is trying to route around it by 50 miles or more- not pick our way through some shrinking 5 mile gap. We CAN do stuff like that, but it's a last resort. Airline world is quite safe. If I say "hell no I'm not flying through that" not one person is going to push back on me. We give this kind of weather a wide berth and if we can't, we just wait it out. Sucks for the passengers but the other option is alot worse.

Not dumb at all- many pilots don't understand how quickly you can accelerate by pointing the nose down. You can go to idle- and I'm sure they did. Think about this: It's a 23,000 lb airplane. The engines produce 9,000lb of thrust- that is enough to push it up to 51,000 ft and well past 500 knots in level flight. When it's pointed straight down, even if the engines are off, you have 23,000 pounds pushing you forward (force of gravity). So you can imagine how fast it will accelerate when it starts descending.
No need to imagine acceleration due to gravity is 9.8m/sec^2 one of my kid’s favorite experiments and mine… over the years they dropped everything imaginable off every balcony on three levels… built drop rigs and timers :) home schooling science was fun!
 
My high school physics teacher was an inspiration and mentor for me to engineering and way better than any professor I ever had… :)
Same.

My physics prof at Michigan Tech walks in 1st day of class, jeans, black Metallica t shirt, socks didnt match, coke bottle glasses and probably hadn't showered in a week.

Dude was smart as could be, but a terrible teacher.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 27
Back
Top